Sunday, February 21, 2010

More TV Examples

I think my favorite example of someone who has adopted a Cartesian philosophy is Dr. Gregory House, the main character of the fictional TV show House, M.D. Obviously, being a fictional TV show, certain aspects of Dr. House's persona are far more extreme than could be considered realistic (if you've seen the show, you know what I mean... he can be a complete monster sometimes). However, the writing is extremely smart usually, as can be seen from the obvious parallels between Dr. House and Sherlock Holmes (according to the producers, the similarities are intended). Here is a man who will stop at nothing to get to the truth. His love of reason and logic is often at odds with the consciences of his co-workers, which creates a lot of the driving emotion for the show. His inability to leave things unexplained is a common focus point of the show (such as Kutner's unexplained suicide), and his sense of right and wrong are easily skewed while in pursuit of the "truth" (he claims the Hippocratic Oath nullifies a "Do Not Resuscitate" clause in one episode, but helps a man commit suicide to save his son in another). I think part of what makes him so fascinating is that he does not fall prey to some forms of dualism that you see in most people. To quote Dr. House, "There HAS to be a reason." He epitomizes the Cartesian philosophy of categorizing everything, and valuing reason above all else.

2 comments:

  1. I think Dexter is also an interesting tv example of Cartesian logic. It's a little different because Dexter is actually a sociopath while House just seems to be unfeeling, but is relatable because we all know that at his heart, he really does care about people, at least some people. Dexter, however (I've only watched one season so I don't know for sure) is unique because we are supposed to be watching a protagonist that really does NOT have any emtions and operates solely on logic.

    He kills people who desreve to be killed, but does so only after research, only after finding proof, a REASON, for them to be murdered. He fills in the gap that other people are not capable of filling because they are hindered by their emotions. He's also contrasted by other characters that have emotional motivations for their actions instead of logical ones, and I think both shows are most worth discussing right now because they are both quite popular.

    Most of us are probably more like the supporting cast than we are like House or Dexter, but we still love watching shows with protagonists that rely solely (or mostly) on logic. I think this more than anything else displays our country's fascination with Cartesian thought, because we don't find these two men dispicable. We in a lot of ways envy them, because they are capable of thinking without their emotions getting in the way.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I'm thinking our X-Files / Dexter / House thread here is VERY Cartesian: these give us a place to play when our world is way, way too rational.

    ReplyDelete